The Enlightenment was a period of immense change. Science replaced a lot of superstitious beliefs, ancient traditions and religions were discarded and debased, and the goal of equality was first introduced. David Stove is a rare critic of the Enlightenment. He was not religious, yet he defended religion against some attacks by Enlightenment thinkers. Though he smashed many idols himself, Stove warned that carelessly dismantling traditions could have dire consequences. His strongest attacks are directed at the notion of equality and the inevitability of progress. These are the topics of the first section of the book.
The first essay is a defense of privilege. The word has taken on an increasingly negative meaning in recent years, implying that privilege is unearned or robbed from others. Stove's opinion was that men of privilege are responsible for the vast majority of cultural and intellectual output. Not kings and queens, but people who have at minimum: access to books, leisure time, and peace and quiet. Karl Marx believed that in a classless society, anyone could be an artist, writer or thinker. This was absurd to Stove. He argued that the idea of equality is so dangerous and destructive that it ought to be illegal to express. Interestingly, the editor of this volume, Andrew Irvine, wrote a forceful riposte against this opinion in the introduction.
Stove then moves on to question whether the human progress promised by the Enlightenment was a promise kept by accident. In 1700 or even 1850, very little progress had been made towards curing diseases, reducing man's labor burden, or increasing the food supply. This is in spite of many great scientific advances that had already been made. Stove made the additional point that the pursuit of equality and creation of social welfare programs should have bankrupted most societies. However, the near simultaneous inventions of electricity and the internal combustion engine created immense prosperity that no one could have predicted. Except for the most disastrous implementations of communism, these inventions prevented the collapse of egalitarian societies under the weight of Enlightenment social projects.
Educationism was another Enlightenment belief that Stove dismissed. The idea is that man can be perfected through education. Stove brings up the point that very few drivers of a car are capable of repairing a car and even fewer car mechanics could have ever invented a sequential gearbox. The people who are capable of making these advancements are one in a million. Stove brings up several great scientists, who received the same education as their peers, but produced vastly more knowledge. Michael Faraday pioneered electricity in spite of a relatively privileged upbringing.
The second section of the book discusses why the world is the way it is. The key figure here is Thomas Malthus, who wrote the influential Essay on the Principle of Population (1798). This essay was written as a political polemic intending to attack the proto-welfare state forming in England. It was purely by accident that his ideas gave Charles Darwin the spark to formulate the theory of evolution by natural selection. Malthus' population principle is that any species is always at or rapidly approaching the limit of its food supply. As a result, there is a struggle for survival among members of a species. This idea provided the motive force for natural selection that Darwin needed. However, Malthus' point in writing the essay was that social welfare programs would create more of the problem it intends to solve. By giving money to feed the poor, they will increase in number, but not increase the food supply. The confiscation of money from the rest of the population will drive people on the margin into poverty. So, it is a vicious cycle.
The ideas of Malthus and Darwin were soon employed by eugenicists and contraceptionists. At the time, the contraceptionists were considered to be the social pariahs of the two. The eugenicists believed that society would be overrun by the poor, so only the best and brightest should be encouraged to procreate. Eventually, the eugenicists saw contraception as a valuable tool in its endeavor, so they forged an alliance. Stove strongly denounced both ideas and called contraception (especially abortion), the “diabolical” secret of the Enlightenment.
Reverend Thomas Malthus was a very well-liked and respected man in his time. However, by the late 1800s, his name became associated with Darwinism (which attacked religion) and contraception (a taboo in Victorian England). He had also attacked the great Enlightenment projects directed towards the goal of equality. The name Malthus was now spat upon by both sides.
Stove also wrote of what he called a “paralytic epistemology.” This is a belief system that leaves you numb and then defenseless, like a spider stung by a wasp. It begins with the idea that “politically, everything is permissible.” Step two is: “morally, everything is permissible.” While this leads to social destruction, it continues on for three more steps: scientifically, methodologically, and cognitively, everything is permissible. This is the irrationalist philosophy he attacked in Popper and After. Once a person has gone down this path, they are paralyzed and defenseless against threats such as communism.
The third section of On Enlightenment is called “Reclaiming the Jungle.” It primarily consists of Stove's three-part essay, Why You Should be a Conservative. It also attacks feminism, which was on the rise during Stove's academic career at the University of Sydney. They were enforcing a policy of only hiring women until some level of parity was reached. Stove opposed this within his philosophy department on the grounds that they should hire the best philosopher, even if it was a broomstick.
Stove's argument for conservatism rests largely on the idea of unintended consequences. Even the most benevolent interventions in society have negative downstream effects. If a disease is eradicated in a native people, this could lead to a population boom, which causes a famine, which increases dependency on imported food, which destroys local culture. In other words, “the road to hell is paved with good intentions.”
Stove believed that benevolence was actually the largest contributor to misery in the modern world. The desire to create an egalitarian worker's paradise led to nothing but mass graveyards everywhere the ideas of Karl Marx were dutifully employed. In spite of the catastrophes, cruelties, and the horrors inflicted on their own people, Stove argued that the “emotional fuel” driving Lenin, Pol Pot, Mao, and others was benevolence.
Another belief that Stove counted as unique to the conservative position is that the existence of a wrong does not imply a logical or moral imperative to right it. There are some necessary evils in the world which cannot be eradicated. In other cases, the cure can be worse than the disease itself. Stove argued that conservatives are often right on social reforms because they tend to act in areas where they are personally involved or have a stake in the outcome. A person (usually a politician) who tries to solve a problem through the collective action of others often creates an outcome worse than leaving the problem alone.
Stove ends the book on a pessimistic note asking the reader to identify a list of ways human flourishing has increased over the past twenty years as respect for life and property have diminished. “Any takers?”