David Stove's book defends the idea of probability against the skepticism of philosopher David Hume. Stove agrees that probable inference, which is to make predictions in spite of uncertainty, isn't perfect. Even if the starting facts are true, the conclusion of a probable inference can be wrong. Stove says that probability theory determines how facts about probability relate to each other, not about the facts themselves. He compares it to a mathematical theorem that calculates the lengths of the sides of a triangle. It's not the specific lengths you put into the formula that are important, but the principles that make it work.
The main idea of probability is that two arguments can have different levels of certainty, even if neither is completely true. But some people think an argument is either completely true or completely false. Stove's book tries to argue against this idea, which was argued by David Hume.
David Hume was a famous Scottish philosopher who many consider one of the greatest. He was a key figure in the Enlightenment and aimed to create a new understanding of the mind and knowledge. He was known for his skepticism and atheism, which led people to call him “the great infidel.” He sometimes published his controversial ideas anonymously, but people quickly figured out it was him.
David Stove was really interested in Hume's skepticism about induction. Induction is a process used in science where you start by observing something carefully, perhaps many times, and then make a general conclusion. Even though science has been very successful, Hume didn't think induction was reasonable. He thought that unless there was a force or something that guarantees the future will behave like the past, then it is unreasonable to make predictions based on observations. For example, he didn't think it was reasonable to expect all fires to be hot just because you've seen ten (or even a thousand) fires and all were hot.
People didn't take Hume's doubts about induction very seriously when he was alive. Newton's laws of physics could predict things so accurately that people believed they were true with absolute certainty. Science was so successful that they thought Hume was being overly skeptical. But nearly 200 years later, Einstein's theory of relativity showed that the way scientists thought about nature wasn't complete. This made people think Hume had been right to doubt induction, and his ideas became part of mainstream philosophy of science through the work of Karl Popper and others.
Stove carefully explained Hume's argument against induction. The argument has two parts:
First, he was skeptical of a priori inferences, which are conclusions drawn before any observation or experience. He believed that these inferences could be wrong even if the facts they're based on are right. Because of this, he thought all a priori inferences were unreasonable.
Second, Hume made a similar case about inductive inferences, which are conclusions drawn from observations. Stove agreed that these inferences can be wrong. To make inductive arguments valid, you'd need to assume that the future will be like the past. But this assumption would be an inductive inference and could be disproven by observation. So, you end up with a circular argument: you can't justify using induction without assuming that the future will resemble the past, but you can't justify that assumption without using induction. Therefore, Hume concluded that all inductive inferences are unreasonable.
Stove noticed a connection between the two parts of Hume's argument: both assume that any inference that isn't necessarily true is unreasonable. He called this belief “deductivism”. Deductivists believe that only completely valid deductive inferences (logically true conclusions) are reasonable. This belief eliminates learning from observation and experience, and also from reasoning with probability theory. This has big implications for science, which relies heavily on these types of reasoning.
Another less obvious result comes from comparing the first and second parts of Hume's argument. If a priori inferences (conclusions made without observation or experience) are equally as unjustified as inductive inferences (conclusions made after observations), then you reach an interesting conclusion. Any belief formed from any amount of experience is just as unjustified as it was before you had any experience.
Stove agrees that inductive inferences can be wrong, but he doesn't think that makes inductive inferences unreasonable. He strongly disagreed with deductivism, the belief that only completely valid deductive inferences are justified, because he thought it led to irrational thinking. He argued against the skeptical view of induction by showing that evidence actually matters when you're testing a hypothesis. For example, if you're testing the hypothesis that all Australian ravens are black, the skeptical view would say that it's just as likely to be true before you've seen any ravens as it is after you've seen many black ravens. This would mean that the evidence doesn't matter. But if you see a raven that isn't black, that disproves the hypothesis, so the evidence must matter. The skeptical view is wrong because it says the probability of the hypothesis is the same before and after you see any evidence, even though seeing a non-black raven would make the probability of the hypothesis zero.
Stove's argument, while complex, supports the common-sense idea that our experiences and observations are important when we make inferences from the observed to the unobserved. This is important because we often have to make judgments based on probability in our everyday lives. For example, detectives, judges, and ordinary people often need to decide whether new evidence changes what they think about a hypothesis.
Stove's main argument against Hume is actually an argument against deductivism, the belief that only completely valid deductive inferences are reasonable. He agrees with some parts of Hume's argument, like the idea that inductive inferences can be wrong and that there's no guarantee that the future will resemble the past. But he doesn't agree with Hume's skepticism about induction, which says that all inductive inferences are equally unjustified. Stove doesn't argue in favor of any specific inductive inference, like the idea that all ravens are black. Instead, he argues that inductive arguments in general can have different degrees of certainty. This is a really important idea because, as Laplace said, “the entire system of human knowledge” depends on the theory of probability.
Week 4-6: Introduction to Probability
- Understanding the concept of Probability
- Why is Probability crucial
- Fun ways to practically understand and implement Probability
Week 7-8: Exploring David Humes Concepts
- Who is David Hume
- Understanding Humes Philosophies
- Debate: Inductive Vs Deductive reasoning
Week 9: Inductive Scepticism
- A study on Hume's 'A Treatise of Human Nature'
- The problem of Induction
- Understanding Humes Inductive Scepticism
Week 10: Application of Probability & Inductive Scepticism
- Applying teachings from Hume's philosophies in daily life and decision making
- The role of probability in everyday life.
- Real world examples of inductive scepticism
Week 11: Reflection and Evaluation
- Review of learnt concepts
- Practical application in daily life
- Essay/Project: Analysis of the book 'Probability and Humes inductive scepticism' by David Owen
Week 12: Feedback and Course Completion
- Feedback on the entire course
- Assessment of understanding
- Handing out course completion certificates
The curriculum may be adjusted as per the learning pace and interest areas of the child. Also, ensure interactive teaching methodologies and practical examples for better understanding.